Tuesday, October 23, 2012

Pages 193-295 Reflection


     In the third section of the book, some very unexpected events happened.  Although unexpected, that is not to say that they were not meaningful and important.  As this book is continuing on, you can see a character change in the main character Mattie Gokey.  One incident where a change may be spotted is when she finally gets the job at the Glenmore Hotel.  I’m disappointed with her fathers ways, “I was to receive four dollars a week. Pa said I could keep a dollar back for myself.  I told him I would keep two or I would not go” (242).  It is great to see Mattie finally standing up to her father and asserting herself telling him what she wants to do.  But I would like to ask why her father is so stubborn in the first place.  I understand that the whole family isn’t doing so great, but if Mattie has a future let her live it.
     Another shocker was the whole incident with Mattie and Royal.  Things seem to be heating up in this relationship, and Royal asks Mattie to marry him!  This is very contradicting because if they marry each other then say good-bye to Barnard College and that whole dream thing she had because it’s OVER.  I can’t wait to see what will happen later in the book and which path she will take.  Another thing that can leave someone in awe including Mattie herself is that her teacher, Miss Wilcox is one of the authors/poets that she reads about.  “Baxter? Baxter! Then you’re not…then that…that makes you…” “Emily Baxter, poet.” (221).  This is amazing because Emily Baxter is the author of one of the poems that Mattie is reading.  One question I would like to ask is why didn’t Miss Wilcox let Mattie know who she was?  There must be a hidden reason behind that, and I would like to see if there is ever a reason for not telling. 
     Another topic that struck very interesting to me was the speaking of God being a man or woman.  Obviously there are different views of men and women, and that adds to the unique qualities that every individual has.  While Mattie is thinking to herself she strikes an appealing hypothesis. She thinks, “What if God was a woman? Would the pop be out of a job? Would the president be a woman, too? And the governor? And the sheriff? And when people got married, would the man have to honor and obey? Would only women be allowed to vote?” (208).  His is interesting because I have never thought of this, and I’m sure many others haven’t either.  We all consider God a man but why? I like to see this kind of thinking by Mattie Gokey, and as usual she always finds ways to impress me.  This is a very serious topic, and I hope that the author will continue throwing these types of questions at us, waiting for the reader to answer. I think the finish to this book will be a strong one, and I can’t wait to continue reading.

2 comments:

  1. I also felt strongly about the topics in this section that you pointed out. There were many surprises throughout the reading. I was very happy to find out that she was finally going to be working at the Glenmore and earning money. I was even happier to see the character change in Mattie. In this section she finally started to mature and stand up for herself. With her new sense of assertivness she was able to stand up to her father and keep some of the money that she rightfully deserved. I was proud of her at this point, however not so much with her agreement to marry Royal. This was a huge surprise and although she's happy the whole situation makes me disappointed. As you stated this dissolves her dream of going to Barnard. I hope somehow as the reading continues that she will be able to go to college.
    I also agree with what you stated concerning women's rights. This was a big part of life at this time. The inequality distinctively shows the time period of this books and it brings up some conflicting ideas for the reader. I find these controversial topics to be fascinating and I also hope to read more about them in the next section.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Brian, I agree with you that it was nice to see Mattie finally standing up for herself and how she now has to make the decision on whether to marry Royal, but I think she really needs to look at her options. I think it was a little selfish of her to want to keep a lot of money for herself when she could be helping her family tremendously. And then there is Royal. I think she really needs to get her priorities straight and decide what she wants more. Does she want to recieve a good education at Barnard College? Or does she want to keep the farm life, marry Royal, and risk everything that she has worked so hard for. I understand that she is being faced with many difficult decisions, but they are ones she really needs to think long and hard about before she jumps into them. It will be interesting to see what exactly her next move will be.

    ReplyDelete